This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

0
Sale
Key Lime Pie (Pre Order)
Sale
Load image into Gallery viewer, Key Lime Pie (Pre Order)

Key Lime Pie (Pre Order)

A Spilt Milk Classic ... and our best selling pie! Creamy key lime filling in a homemade graham cracker crust shell, topped with freshly whipped cream + a generous sprinkling of fresh lime zest 🌴

World's Best Key Lime Pie!

Each 9" pie serves 6-8 slices. 2 days advance notice required for pre-orders. 

 

**This product listing is for a key lime pie pre-order. To order for same-day pickup, please scroll to the top of the page and click on the Pie menu from the Same Day order dropdown. Same Day ordering is available during business hours. Thanks!
  • Your Cart Subtotal$45.00

© 2025 Spilt Milk Pastry | Powered by Shopify