Easter Pre-Orders 2025

Pickup for all Easter pre-orders will be on Saturday, April 19th. We are closed on Easter Sunday - April 20! 

Our Easter pre-order menu this year includes:

• 🐷 Quiche Lorraine - Slagel Family Farms shaved ham, creamy gruyere cheese, caramelized onions, fresh chopped herbs & grainy mustard  (serves 6-8)
  
• 🌱 Spring Veggie Quiche - Fresh Spring asparagus, chévre cheese, caramliezed onions, & fresh herbs  (serves 6-8)
• 🧈 Scone Sampler - A half dozen of our famous Spilt Milk scones - Lemon Lavender, Brown Sugar Maple, and Citrus Ginger (2 scones per flavor)
• ☕️ Cinnamon Sugar Coffee Cake - Our best-selling, buttery coffee cake laced with freshly ground Vietnamese cinnamon. Pair with coffee or tea and curl up on the couch! (serves 8-10)
• 🪺 Coconut Cream Pie - Our decadent coconut cream pie dressed up for Easter Sunday with coconut flakes & chocolate eggs ... looks just like a spring birds nest! 
  
• 🍋 Creamy Lemon Cheesecake Pie - Freshly squeezed lemons are the star of the show in this classic cheesecake pie! We bake this light & fluffy cheesecake inside a homemade lemon snap cookie crust, then top with fresh vanilla whip cream, candied lemon peel, and fresh lemon zest. 
• 🥧 Mixed Berry Rhubarb Pie - Plump Michigan raspberries, blueberries, & raspberries blended with tangy, sweet Spring rhubarb lovingly baked in our signature hand-rolled, all-butter pie crust - topped with crunchy & sweet oat crumble topping 
• 🌴 Key Lime Pie - A Spilt Milk Classic ... and our best selling pie! Creamy key lime filling in a homemade graham cracker crust shell, topped with freshly whipped cream + a generous sprinkling of fresh lime zest 
• 🍫 Chocolate Cream Pie - Decadent chocolate pastry cream inside our homemade chocolate sable cookie crust, topped with lightly sweetened, freshly whipped cream, dark chocolate ganache drizzle, and plenty of chocolate cookie crumbles - a chocolate-lovers dream! 😍
• 🥕 Carrot Cake Cupcakes - Our homemade carrot cake baked freshly grated carrots & golden raisins, topped with a swirl of cream cheese icing. A half-dozen cupcakes per box *Recipe includes walnuts!
• 🐰 DIY Cookie Decorating Kit - A half-dozen bunny shaped sugar cookies, plus our homemade buttercream icing and plenty of sprinkles for you to decorate your bunnies at home!

Pre-order pickup will be on Saturday, April 19th from 8am-5pm. We are closed on Easter Sunday - April 20th!

OTHER INFO >>

If we are sold out of your preferred pie flavor or item, please know that we always make EXTRA pies and pastries that will be available for same-day pickup. You are welcome to purchase in-store or online for same-day pickup!

By placing an order, you consent to our refund, cancellation, & "forgotten order" policy. Click here to read the policy in full.

If you have any questions or need help, please don't hesitate to reach out via email to hello@spiltmilkpastry.com and someone from our team will get back to you 😍

Happy Easter! 🐰 🥕