UPDATE: We are SOLD OUT of our Pi Day pre-orders at this time! If you missed the pre-order period, don't despair ... we will be baking extra pies for pickup on Friday, March 14th! Please stop by to shop with us in person starting at 8am (or order online starting at 8am) if you'd still like to get a pie for Pi Day! Be sure to COME EARLY because we tend to sell out of pie on Pi Day!
Happy Pi Day - 3.14! I'll take any excuse to eat pie, so let's get to it. WHEN ORDERING, please. be sure to read all the information on this page for pickup instructions (below).
➡️ NOTE: 9" pies are our "regular" size and serve 6-8 people. 6" pies are our "mini" size and serve 2-3 people.
Our pre-order menu this year includes:
-
Key Lime Pie: A Spilt Milk Classic ... and our best selling pie! Creamy key lime filling in a homemade graham cracker crust shell, topped with freshly whipped cream + a generous sprinkling of fresh lime zest 🌴
-
Blueberry Rhubarb Pie: Voted "Best Pie in Chicago" by Chicago Magazine in 2019 - a must-try! A blend of juicy Michigan blueberries & tart spring rhubarb baked into our signature hand-rolled, all-butter pie crust & topped with a crunchy oat crumble topping 🫐
-
Peanut Butter Mousse Pie: Homemade chocolate sable cookie crust filled with decadent, fluffy peanut butter mousse & topped with a thin layer of peanut butter glaze, dark chocolate ganache drizzle, & chocolate crispies 🥜
-
Lemon Meringue Pie: Creamy lemon filling inside a homemade graham cracker crust, topped with an impressive cloud of whipped meringue, and toasted to perfection 🍋
-
S'Mores Pie: Just like the classic campfire treat - in pie form! Dark chocolate ganache pie filling inside our homemade graham cracker cookie crust, topped with toasty marshmallow topping, drizzled with dark chocolate ganache & topped with chocolate crispies 🔥
-
Chocolate Cream Pie: Our take on the classic French Silk Pie ... Dark chocolate pastry cream is lovingly folded inside our homemade chocolate sable cookie crust, then topped with a cloud of freshly whipped cream, more cookie crumbles, and a chocolate ganache drizzle 🍫
-
Lemon Cloud Pie: Homemade lemon curd layered with vanilla pastry cream, then topped with freshly whipped cream & white chocolate crispearls inside our signature hand-rolled, all-butter pie crust ... like a decadent, light, fluffy lemon cloud! ⛅️ (9" only)
-
Apple Raspberry Crumble Pie: Michigan heirloom-variety apples and fall raspberries are expertly blended and baked inside our hand-rolled, all-butter pie crust, then topped with a crunchy oat crumble topping for the perfect sweet/tart fruit pie combo! 🍎 (9" only)
-
Coconut Cream Pie: Decadent coconut-kissed pastry cream is piled high inside our signature hand-rolled, all-butter pie crust and topped with plenty of toasted coconut for that perfect crunch! This is the best coconut cream pie on the planet!! 🥥 (9" only)
🚗 Pi Day order pickups will be on Friday, March 14th. You are welcome to pick up your order any time between 8am-5pm on that date!
If you have any questions or need help ordering, please don't hesitate to give us a call at the shop (708.613.4403) or send us an email (hello@spiltmilkpastry.com) and someone from our team will get back to you ASAP.
By placing an order, you consent to our refund, cancellation, & "forgotten order" policy. Click here to read the policy in full.
Happy Pi Day!!
