Valentine's Day Pre-Orders 2025

Valentine's Day is Friday, February 14th ... don't forget to order some treats for your sweetie! Pickup for all Valentine's Day pre-orders will be on Friday, February 14th from 8am-5pm. If you'd like to place an order for a different day, please call the shop at (708) 613-4403 or order online from our regular pre-order menu (linked here).

➡️ NOTE: 9" pies are our "regular" size and serve 6-8 people. 6" pies are our "mini" size and serve 2-3 people.

Our Valentine's Day menu this year includes:

• ♥️ Raspberry Chocolate Cream Pie: Our classic chocolate cream pie with a Valentine's twist! Topped with raspberry-kissed whip cream, cookie crumbles, ruby chocolate drizzle, & Valentine-themed sprinkles
• ❤️‍🔥 Passionfruit Raspberry Cheesecake: Passionfruit cheesecake laced with raspberry jam and topped with a cloud of raspberry whip cream & pie cookie "hearts"
• 🍒 Tart Cherry Pie: Michigan tart cherries from our friends at Ellis Family Farms are lovingly baked inside our signature hand-rolled, all-butter double pie crust - a classic pie that's perfect for sharing with the ones you love!
• 🍫 Chocolate Truffle Pound Cake: A chocolate-lovers dream! Our dark chocolate sour cream pound cake is truly perfection, topped with a rich, chocolate ganache frosting, cocoa nibs, chocolate crispies, and a sprinkle of sea salt ... you do NOT want to miss this delicious Spilt Milk classic! (6-8 servings per loaf)
• 🍓 Cupcakes & Chocolate-Covered Strawberries: Perfect for gifting or enjoying with loved ones! Each box includes 3 dark chocolate cupcakes with chocolate buttercream icing and 3 chocolate covered strawberries (half-dozen treats per box total)
• 🎨 Cookie Decorating Kit: All the supplies you need to have a cookie decorating party with your Valentines! Each kit includes four heart-shaped sugar cookie cutouts, plus buttercream frosting in a piping bag & Valentine-themed sprinkles.
  
• 💐 Fresh Flower Bouquet: A beautiful Valentine's Day bouquet of fresh flowers from our friends at Pickle Hill Parties. Limited quantities available - pre-order only!

Please pick up your order any time between 8am-5pm on Friday, February 14 2025!