Mother's Day Pre-Orders

Happy Mother's Day! Celebrate the momma or mom figure in your life with a special treat from Spilt Milk 🥰

Mother's Day pickups will be on Saturday, May 10th or Sunday, May 11th. Please take care when selecting your pickup date - the deadline to change or cancel your order is Monday, May 5th.

Our Mother's Day pre-order menu this year includes:

🍓 Strawberry Lemonade Pie: Lemon cream pie inside our homemade graham cracker crust, topped with fluffy strawberry-kissed whipped cream and farm fresh strawberries - a beautiful pie for springtime!

🫐 Mixed Berry Rhubarb Pie: Tart spring rhubarb pairs perfectly with juicy, sweet, farm fresh berries. We lovingly fold the fruit into our signature all-butter double pie crust and and bake to a deep, golden brown. Yum!

🌴 Key Lime Pie: Tart & creamy key lime filling in our homemade graham cracker crust, topped with freshly whipped cream and lime zest. I'll keep saying it until someone makes it official ... this is the World's Best Key Lime Pie!

🍫 Chocolate Cream Pie: Rich chocolate pastry cream baked in our homemade chocolate sable cookie crust, topped with fresh whipped cream, more chocolate cookie crumbles & a drizzle of dark chocolate ganache

☕️ Spilt Milk's Tiramisu: Crisp ladyfingers dipped in freshly brewed Metric espresso & French Cognac, blanketed in creamy, light as a feather mascarpone cream, and dusted with the finest quality cocoa powder 

🌸 Plum Streusel Coffee Cake with Frangipane Swirl: Our yummy all-butter coffee cake gets a glow-up for spring, infused with fresh plums & swirled with a decadent frangipane ripple throughout (serves 10-12)

🧈 Scone Sampler Box: A half-dozen of our beloved scones - each box includes 2 each of our best selling scones!

🍪 Mother's Day Cookie Box: Baked special just for mom! Expect an assortment of "World Peace" chocolate cookies, sugar cookies, sandwich cookies, almond crescents,  shortbread cookies, biscotti, decorated buttercream sugar cookies. May contain nuts - approximately 18-20 cookies per box. Photo on this page shows a similar (but not identical) cookie box 

🥚 Quiche: IYKYK - Spilt Milk has the best quiche in town, folks! We are offering up a meat option (Shaved Slagel Farms Ham & Creamy Gruyere Cheese), or a veggie option (Spring Asparagus & Chevre with Freshly Chopped Herbs) for Mother's Day this year

💐 Fresh Flower Bouquet: Celebrate Mom with a fresh flower bouquet from Pickle Hill Parties! You'll receive a lush, composed paper wrapped bouquet of flowers and greenery.  Flowers will be selected based on the most beautiful available from our farm partners. Pick up your bouquet with your bakery order at Spilt Milk

By placing a Mother's Day order, you consent to our refund & cancellation policy. The deadline to change or cancel your order is Monday, May 5th. Thank you for ordering from Spilt Milk - Happy Mother's Day!