Spilt Milk Pastry

Order Online

Click below to view our menus & place an order online. Orders for "today" can be placed & picked up during regular business hours. Orders for future dates require a minimum of 48-72 hours advance notice.

Order & Pick Up Today Order For a Future Date

Thanksgiving at Spilt Milk

We are now accepting pre-orders for our Thanksgiving menu! Click below to view our pies, pastries, and other treats available for pickup on 11/26 and 11/27

View Thanksgiving Menu >>

Friday Night Dinner

Our weekly Friday dinner feature is a great way to "hit the easy button" on dinner at the end of a long week, and serve your family & friends something wholesome and delicious! Our menu changes weekly, and each take-and-heat dinner is available in either a two or four-person pack. You can optionally add on our weekly dessert and/or wine feature to make it a party!

View This Week's Menu

Event & Party Catering

We are always so honored to bake for your special events, parties, weddings, and soirees! Click below for more info about our Event & Catering options...

Learn More

"The bakery is top notch. The peanut butter, brown butter, biscuits, and everything I’ve tried are delicious. The shop is a cute place to stop and have a coffee and snack. But don’t skip the sandwiches. I have dreams about how good this garden sandwich is."

Natalie B.
"Amazing coffee, delectable pastries, wonderful baristas. Everything about this place is fabulous. You need to go here to experience it."

Cuyler J.
"Jesus on a bicycle, this is one of the best bakeries I’ve ever been to. I’m typing this as I tuck into a ginormous, buttery, flaky hot biscuit that I’ve slathered with their strawberry rhubarb jam. And their sprinkle sugar cookies and key lime pie and brown sugar cookies and rich savory quiches and hand pies…as you can see I like it here. And so do all the folks I see lined up out the door."
"Spilt Milk continues to impress me. I don’t live in Oak Park, but make a point to stop in anytime I’m in the area for a brown butter cookie or a savory biscuit. The staff are always so friendly and welcoming. They also have an amazing selection of dry goods, great stuff to grab if you’re have a party or need a unique gift (including an eclectic wine selection!) You can tell the team here truly cares about their business, their product, and their customers. Happy to continue to support this small business."

Connor K.
"Oak Park's greatest bakery and pastry shop. While their reputation is built on their pies, scones, cookies, and other baked goods, don't overlook their lunch items. They are just as incredible as the rest of the menu."

Etienne P.
"We love Spilt Milk! There are so many delicious goodies to try - but my favorites include their iced oat milk latte with (house-made!) lavender syrup, guava cream pie, handpies, and Mexican chocolate cookies. Yum!! Their new space on South Blvd has an awesome patio in the back to hang out in! This bakery is definitely an Oak Park staple!"

Kristen H.